How the waterfall is set up
The LP puts in 90% of the $10,000,000 equity and the GP 10%. The deal pays $500,000 to $650,000 a year and $15,600,000 in year 5, including the sale. The split:
- Tier 1: 90/10, pro rata to the equity, until the LP has earned an 8% IRR on its capital.
- Tier 2: everything above the hurdle 70/30. The GP's 30% instead of 10% is the promote.
Real deals often have two or three hurdles, for example 8%, 12% and 15% with rising GP splits. Each extra hurdle is one more balance of the same kind.
Step 1: the LP hurdle balance
The balance starts at the LP's contribution, $9,000,000. Each year it grows at the hurdle rate and falls by the LP's tier-1 cash: =C3*(1+$B$10)-D3*$B$11. The yearly cash is less than 8% of the balance, so the balance keeps rising: $9,270,000 at the start of year 2, $9,516,600 in year 3, $9,737,928 in year 4 and $9,931,962 in year 5. Unpaid return is carried forward and compounds, exactly like an IRR.
Step 2: tier 1 cash
Tier 1 pays the deal cash, but no more than what clears the hurdle. Because the LP gets only 90% of each tier-1 dollar, the deal must send the LP's need divided by 90%: =MIN(B7,C7*(1+$B$10)/$B$11). In years 1 to 4 all cash is tier 1. In year 5 the LP needs $9,931,962 × 1.08 = $10,726,519, so tier 1 takes $11,918,355 of the $15,600,000 and the LP balance is exactly zero afterwards. At that point the LP has earned exactly 8% IRR.
Step 3: the cash above the hurdle and the promote
The remaining $3,681,645 is split 70/30. The LP's cash in each year is tier 1 × 90% + tier 2 × 70%, which gives $13,303,671 in year 5. The GP's promote is the extra 20 points it receives above its pro rata 10% on the cash above the hurdle: $3,681,645 × 20% = $736,329.
Worked example: 8% LP IRR hurdle, 70/30 above it
A fictional apartment joint venture. Column B is the deal's equity cash flow, rows 10 to 12 are the deal terms and rows 13 to 19 the results.
| A | B | C | D | E | F | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Year | Deal cash flow | LP hurdle balance, start | Tier 1 cash | Cash above hurdle | LP cash flow |
| 2 | 0 | -10,000,000 | -9,000,000 | |||
| 3 | 1 | 500,000 | 9,000,000 | 500,000 | 0 | 450,000 |
| 4 | 2 | 550,000 | 9,270,000 | 550,000 | 0 | 495,000 |
| 5 | 3 | 600,000 | 9,516,600 | 600,000 | 0 | 540,000 |
| 6 | 4 | 650,000 | 9,737,928 | 650,000 | 0 | 585,000 |
| 7 | 5 | 15,600,000 | 9,931,962 | 11,918,355 | 3,681,645 | 13,303,671 |
| 8 | Total | 7,900,000 | 14,218,355 | 3,681,645 | 6,373,671 | |
| 9 | Terms and results | Value | ||||
| 10 | LP IRR hurdle (tier 1) | 8.0% | ||||
| 11 | LP share, tier 1 (pro rata) | 90% | ||||
| 12 | LP share above the hurdle | 70% | ||||
| 13 | Deal IRR | 13.38% | ||||
| 14 | LP IRR after promote | 12.28% | ||||
| 15 | Equity multiple, deal | 1.79x | ||||
| 16 | GP total cash received | 2,526,329 | ||||
| 17 | GP promote (above its pro rata share) | 736,329 | ||||
| 18 | GP share of total profit | 19.3% | ||||
| 19 | LP hurdle balance after the sale (check) | 0 |
- C4
=C3*(1+$B$10)-D3*$B$11Hurdle balance grows at 8%, falls with LP cash - D7
=MIN(B7,C7*(1+$B$10)/$B$11)Tier 1 cash in the sale year - F7
=D7*$B$11+E7*$B$12LP cash: 90% of tier 1, 70% above - B14
=IRR(F2:F7)LP IRR after the promote - B18
=(B16+B2*(1-B11))/B8GP share of total profit
Educational only, not investment, legal or tax advice. Real waterfalls follow the operating agreement, which may define hurdles, catch-ups and timing differently.
Step 4: check the result
- LP IRR:
=IRR(F2:F7)= 12.28%. It must land between the 8% hurdle and the 13.38% deal IRR, because the promote comes out of the return above the hurdle. - GP share of the profit: the GP receives $2,526,329 for its $1,000,000, a profit of $1,526,329 out of a total deal profit of $7,900,000, or 19.3%. Sponsors and LPs often quote this effective share.
- Balance check: the LP hurdle balance after the sale is 0. If it is negative, tier 1 paid too much.
The deal also returns a 1.79x equity multiple. Many LPs ask for an equity multiple hurdle on top of the IRR hurdle, because a quick sale can clear an IRR hurdle with little profit in dollars. For the basics of the IRR itself, see how to calculate IRR in Excel, and for the property income behind the cash flows, cap rate calculation.
American vs European waterfalls and other terms
This is a single-deal waterfall. In a fund with several properties, an American (deal-by-deal) waterfall pays the promote on each deal as it is sold, while a European (whole-fund) waterfall pays it only after the LPs have received their capital and preferred return across the whole fund, which is safer for LPs. Other terms change the math: a catch-up lets the GP receive most of the cash after the hurdle until it reaches its target share, the hurdle may be tested on LP or on total equity, and the pref may be simple or compounding. Read the operating agreement and model what it says.
Common mistakes
- Forgetting to gross up tier 1. The LP gets only 90% of each tier-1 dollar. Divide the LP's need by its share, or the hurdle is never quite reached.
- Using a simple pref when the agreement says IRR. An IRR hurdle compounds unpaid return. A simple 8% a year on capital gives a different, usually lower, tier 1.
- Testing the hurdle on deal cash instead of LP cash. Check which the agreement uses. The hurdle balance here is tested on the LP.
- Calling all GP cash the promote. The GP's pro rata share is a return on its own capital. Only the cash above that share is promote.
- Not checking the LP IRR. It must sit between the hurdle and the deal IRR. A result outside that range points to a formula error.
- Hard-coding the splits in formulas. Keep hurdle rates and splits in input cells so you can test other terms in seconds.
Frequently asked questions
What is an IRR hurdle in a real estate waterfall?
It is the IRR the investors must earn before the sponsor receives a promote. Cash is split pro rata until the LP reaches the hurdle, then the sponsor's share of further cash goes up.
What is the difference between a preferred return and an IRR hurdle?
A preferred return is often tracked as a separate pref account, sometimes simple and sometimes compounding, next to a return-of-capital account. An IRR hurdle combines capital and return in one compounding balance. With compounding and the same timing, the two give the same result.
How is the GP promote calculated?
Take the cash in each tier above the first hurdle and multiply it by the GP's split minus its pro rata equity share. Here 30% minus 10% on the cash above the 8% hurdle.
Why is the LP IRR lower than the deal IRR?
Because the GP receives more than its pro rata share of the cash above the hurdle. The promote is paid out of the LP's share of the upside, so the LP IRR falls between the hurdle and the deal IRR.